Neser's brilliant catch within the Laws, but do they needing changing?

Michael Neser's spectacular boundary catch to remove Jordan Silk at a vital moment of the high-scoring BBL thriller at the Gabba has reignited the debate about whether the Law regarding such dismissals needs to be amended.

As Silk lofted Mark Steketee towards long-off, Neser first held the ball inside the boundary then tossed it up when he realised he would run over the rope. What followed was the astonishing part. Neser, while outside the boundary, then timed a jump perfectly to palm the ball back inside the rope while he was not touching the ground, then returned into the field of play to hold the catch.

Glenn Maxwell on why Michael Neser's catch was legit

(via @7Cricket) pic.twitter.com/e8ql9vHKu9

— ESPNcricinfo (@ESPNcricinfo) January 1, 2023

"I knew [Matt] Renshaw did it a couple of years ago," Neser told Channel Seven. "I didn't know if they had changed the rules so I thought I would give it a crack. Thankfully they didn't change the rules."

It was entirely within the Laws of the game and was correctly adjudged to be out when it went to the TV umpire, but it created much debate about whether it should be allowed. One view is that it rewards outstanding skill and awareness, as shown by Neser, but the alternative point is that the ball and the fielder have both been over the boundary.

Australia quick Josh Hazlewood said he did not agree with the Law as it was written. "I didn't like it all," he told reporters at the SCG. "I think it should be back to the old rule where you have to be in the field of play and that's your last step before you throw it back in. It was something different and 'Ness' is pretty cluey with the rules. It worked for them last night."

This is how the relevant Law reads, with the key point being that Neser's first touch was inside the field of play and that he was not grounded beyond the boundary while touching the ball again.

"19.5.2 A fielder who is not in contact with the ground is considered to be grounded beyond the boundary if his/her final contact with the ground, before his/her first contact with the ball after it has been delivered by the bowler, was not entirely within the boundary.

"33.2.1 A catch will be fair only if, in every case, either the ball, at any time, or any fielder in contact with the ball, is not grounded beyond the boundary before the catch is completed.

"33.2.2 Furthermore, a catch will be fair if…33.2.2.4 a fielder catches the ball after it has crossed the boundary in the air, provided that the conditions in 33.2.1 are met."

The key points are:

1) The FIRST contact must be inside the boundary, and

2) the fielder can't be touching the ball and the ground beyond the boundary at the same time.#MCCLaws

— Marylebone Cricket Club (@MCCOfficial) January 1, 2023